BlueCollarBench

Ask two AIs a trade question. Pick the better answer.

0/600
Trade

3 questions a day, +2 per vote (max 8). Links are stripped. No personal info.

or grade a random exam task →

Grade an exam task

Two anonymous answers to a real exam question. Pick the one a journeyman would trust. Keys 1–4 vote.

ElectricalExam task · KNOWLEDGETask page

I'm pulling four 20A 120V circuits through one 3/4 EMT from a panel to a shop, each circuit with its own neutral, plus one ground, THHN. Do I need to upsize the wire?

Model A

No, you do not need to upsize the wire for the four 20A 120V circuits in a single 3/4" EMT conduit, as long as you are using THHN/THWN-2 conductors and following NEC requirements.

Here’s the breakdown:

  • Each circuit: 20A, 120V → requires 12 AWG copper THHN (rated for 25A at 90°C, but limited to 20A by the 60°C termination rating per NEC 110.14(C)(1)(a)).
  • You have:
  • 4 circuits × 2 conductors (hot + neutral) = 8 current-carrying conductors
  • 1 equipment grounding conductor (EGC) = 1 non-current-carrying conductor → Total: 9 conductors in the 3/4" EMT.

Conduit Fill Check (NEC Chapter 9, Table 1 & Table 4):

  • 3/4" EMT has a 40% fill area of 0.213 in² (for more than 2 wires).
  • Area of one 12 AWG THHN: 0.0133 in² (NEC Chapter 9, Table 5).
  • 9 × 0.0133 = 0.1197 in² → well under 0.213 in². ✅ Conduit fill is acceptable.

Derating Check (NEC 310.15(C)(1)):

  • More than 3 current-carrying conductors require derating.
  • You have 8 current-carrying conductors (4 hots + 4 neutrals).
  • Derating factor for 4–6 conductors: 80%
  • Derating factor for 7–9 conductors: 70% (NEC Table 310.15(C)(1))
  • 12 AWG THHN: 90°C ampacity = 25A
  • Derated: 25A × 0.70 = 17.5AThis is below 20A!

Problem: The derated ampacity (17.5A) is less than the 20A breaker rating → violation of NEC 240.4(D) and 310.15.

Solution: You must either:

  1. Reduce the number of current-carrying conductors (e.g., use multi-wire branch circuits with shared neutrals — but only if properly handled per 210.4), or
  2. Upsize the wire to compensate for derating.

Recommended Fix: Use 10 AWG THHN for the hots and neutrals:

  • 10 AWG THHN: 90°C ampacity = 35A
  • Derated: 35A × 0.70 = **24.5A

Votes are anonymous and rate-limited (60/day). How ratings work.

Electrical arena ratings

Bradley-Terry fit on blind votes · Elo shown as a secondary number · models under 30 votes are provisional

No ratings yet

Ratings appear after the first votes are recorded and fit. Vote above to get it started.