BlueCollarBench

Ask two AIs a trade question. Pick the better answer.

0/600
Trade

3 questions a day, +2 per vote (max 8). Links are stripped. No personal info.

or grade a random exam task →

Grade an exam task

Two anonymous answers to a real exam question. Pick the one a journeyman would trust. Keys 1–4 vote.

HVACExam task · CODETask page

Electrician isn't coming back. For the condenser, where does the disconnect have to be, and how do I size the breaker and wire off the nameplate?

Model A

For a condenser (outdoor AC unit), the disconnect must be within sight and not more than 50 feet from the unit (NEC 440.14). It must be a readily accessible, lockable disconnecting means — typically a fused or non-fused disconnect switch mounted on the wall or a post near the unit.

Sizing the Breaker and Wire:

Use the nameplate on the condenser to find:

  • MCA (Minimum Circuit Ampacity) → determines wire size
  • MOCP (Maximum Overcurrent Protective Device) → determines breaker/fuse size

Steps:

  1. Wire Size: Select copper wire rated for at least 125% of the MCA (NEC 440.22). Example: If MCA = 18A → 18A × 1.25 = 22.5A → use 12 AWG copper (rated 25A at 75°C). Always check insulation rating (THHN/THWN-2) and conduit fill.
  1. Breaker Size: Select a breaker or fuse not exceeding the MOCP (NEC 440.22). Example: If MOCP = 30A → use a 30A breaker (or dual-element fuse). Do not exceed MOCP — undersizing may cause nuisance trips; oversizing risks fire.
  1. Disconnect Rating: The disconnect must be rated ≥ the nameplate’s rated load current (or ≥ breaker size, whichever is larger). Typically, a 30A or 60A non-fused disconnect is sufficient for residential units.

Important Notes:

  • Always verify voltage (208V/230V or 460V) and phase (single or 3-phase) from nameplate.
  • If the unit has internal overcurrent protection (common), a non-fused disconnect is acceptable.
  • Never guess — if nameplate is missing or unclear, consult a licensed electrician. Incorrect sizing can cause equipment damage, fire, or void warranty.
  • Permit and inspection likely required — check local AHJ.

> ⚠️ If you’re not licensed to work on 240V HVAC circuits, stop and hire a pro. Mistakes here are dangerous and code-violating. > NEC 2023: 440.14, 440.22, 440.32, 440.6(A).

Votes are anonymous and rate-limited (60/day). How ratings work.

HVAC arena ratings

Bradley-Terry fit on blind votes · Elo shown as a secondary number · models under 30 votes are provisional

No ratings yet

Ratings appear after the first votes are recorded and fit. Vote above to get it started.