BlueCollarBench

Trades/Electrical

ElectricalTask EL-023masterCodeUS

My kitchen plan has a 10-foot island with no cabinets, a peninsula, and 14 linear feet of counter along the wall with the sink in the middle.

Prompt as given to every model

My kitchen plan has a 10-foot island with no cabinets, a peninsula, and 14 linear feet of counter along the wall with the sink in the middle. How many receptacles and circuits under the current code, and what changed recently for the island?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Laguna S 2.1Score —

Current NEC 2023 Requirements:

Wall Counter (14 linear ft):

  • Minimum 3 receptacles required (NEC 210.52(C)(1))
  • One within 4 feet of sink, others spaced ≤4 feet apart
  • Must be GFCI protected (210.8(A)(6))

Peninsula:

  • Minimum 1 receptacle (210.52(C)(2))
  • If ≥4 feet long, consider 2 receptacles for convenience

Island (10-foot):

  • Minimum 2 receptacles required (210.52(C)(2))
  • Must be GFCI protected (210.8(A)(6))
  • Receptacles cannot be more than 24 inches apart (210.52(C)(2) Exception)

Recent Changes (2023 NEC):

  • Island receptacles now require GFCI protection - this is new! Previously, island receptacles were exempt from GFCI requirements unless within 6 feet of a sink.
  • The 2020 NEC first introduced GFCI protection for all kitchen island receptacles, and this remains in 2023.

Circuit Requirements:

  • All kitchen countertop receptacles (wall, peninsula, island) must be served by minimum 2 small appliance branch circuits (210.11(C)(1))
  • These circuits cannot serve other outlets (like lighting)
  • GFCI protection can be provided by GFCI circuit breakers or GFCI receptacles

Recommendation: Install at least 2 GFCI-protected circuits for all countertop receptacles, with a minimum of 6 total receptacles (3 wall, 1 peninsula, 2 island). Consider adding a third circuit for the island if you plan high-draw appliances.

522 tokens · 9.7s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Current Code (2023 NEC) Requirements:

Wall Counter (14 ft):

  • Receptacles: Minimum 3 (210.52(A)(1): first 12" + every 48" thereafter). At 14 ft (168"), you need receptacles at ≤12", ≤60", ≤108", ≤156" = 4 receptacles minimum.
  • Circuits: Minimum two 20A small-appliance branch circuits (210.11(C)(1)). These must serve only kitchen/dining/pantry receptacles. Split receptacles across circuits (e.g., 2 per circuit).

Peninsula:

  • Treated as wall counter (210.52(A)(2)). If ≥24" wide, needs receptacle within 12" of end. Counts toward wall spacing.

Island (10 ft, no cabinets):

  • Major 2023 Change: *210.52(C)(3) now requires receptacles for all islands/peninsulas ≥24" x 12" (previously only if ≥9 ft²).*
  • Receptacles: Minimum 2 (one per 9 ft² or fraction thereof; 210.52(C)(3)). For 10 ft island (assume 3–4 ft wide = 30–40 ft²), need 4–5 receptacles.
  • Pop-up receptacles now explicitly permitted (210.52(C)(3) Exception).
  • Circuits: Fed from the two required small-appliance circuits (210.52(B)(1)). No dedicated circuit required unless local amendment.

Summary:

  • Total receptacles: ~8–9 (4 wall + 1 peninsula + 3–4 island).
  • Circuits: Two 20A small-appliance circuits (12/2 AWG CU, GFCI-protected per 210.8(A)(6)).
  • Key 2023 change: Island receptacle mandate lowered from 9 ft² to any island ≥24" x 12".

Verify local adoption—some jurisdictions are on 2020 NEC (island threshold still 9 ft²). Always GFCI-protect all countertop receptacles.

632 tokens · 8.2s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.