BlueCollarBench

Trades/Electrical

ElectricalTask EL-006masterKnowledgeUS

I'm wiring a 10 HP 230V single-phase motor for a shop compressor.

Prompt as given to every model

I'm wiring a 10 HP 230V single-phase motor for a shop compressor. The nameplate says 42 FLA. How do I size the branch circuit conductors and the breaker, and why don't the two match?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Laguna S 2.1Score —

Conductor sizing (NEC 2023):

  • Motor nameplate: 42 FLA.
  • Minimum conductor ampacity = 42 × 1.25 = 52.5 A (NEC 210.19(A)(1)).
  • 6 AWG copper (60°C column, 55–75°C terminations) = 65 A ✅.
  • 4 AWG aluminum = 55 A ✅.

Overcurrent device (NEC 210.20(A)):

  • Max OCPD = 42 × 250% = 105 A.
  • Standard 2-pole breaker: 100 A ✅.

Why they don't match:

  • Conductors are sized at 125% of FLA to prevent insulation damage from continuous current.
  • Breakers are allowed at 250% of FLA because motors draw high inrush current (6–8× FLA) at startup. A 100 A breaker won't nuisance-trip during startup, but 6 AWG conductors still carry the full 42 A safely.

Summary:

  • Conductors: 6 AWG copper or 4 AWG aluminum.
  • Breaker: 100 A 2-pole.
  • Disconnect: Within sight of motor (NEC 210.7).
418 tokens · 11.0s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Conductors: 6 AWG THHN (65 A ampacity). Breaker: 100 A inverse-time (thermal-magnetic).

Why they don’t match Motors draw 6–8× FLA at startup. If the breaker were sized to the conductor ampacity (65 A), it would nuisance-trip on every start. The NEC permits the OCPD to be oversized only for motor-starting inrush; the conductors are still protected against overload by the motor’s own overload device (starter heater or electronic overload).

Step-by-step (2023 NEC)

  1. FLA basis – Use nameplate 42 A (not Table 430.248).
  2. Conductor ampacity – 430.22(A): 125 % × 42 A = 52.5 A. Table 310.16 (75 °C column): 6 AWG CU = 65 A → OK.
  3. Short-circuit/ground-fault OCPD max – 430.52(C)(1) Ex. 2(a): 250 % × 42 A = 105 A. Next standard size down (240.6) = 100 A.
  4. Overload protection – Separate device at 115–125 % FLA (430.32).
  5. Disconnect – 430.110: ≥ 115 % FLA = 48.3 A → 60 A motor-rated switch.
  6. Equipment grounding conductor – 250.122: 100 A OCPD → 8 AWG CU.

Practical notes

  • Torque lugs to manufacturer spec; use 75 °C rated terminals.
  • If run exceeds 100 ft, upsize conductors for voltage drop (3 % max recommended).
  • Verify starter overload dial is set to 42 A.
  • All work per NEC 110.14(C), 300.4, 430.6, 430.22, 430.52, 250.122.
643 tokens · 7.3s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.