BlueCollarBench

Trades/Carpentry & Framing

Carpentry & FramingTask CA-013journeymanKnowledgeUS

I'm building up a three-ply 2x12 girder from 16-foot stock for a 32-foot floor beam over posts.

Prompt as given to every model

I'm building up a three-ply 2x12 girder from 16-foot stock for a 32-foot floor beam over posts. How do I nail it and where do the joints go?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Laguna S 2.1Score —

Three-ply 2x12 Girder Assembly:

Nailing Pattern:

  • Use 16d common nails (3 1/2")
  • Stagger joints between adjacent plies by at least 24 inches
  • Nail spacing: 3 rows per ply interface, 12" o.c. in each row
  • Edge distance: Minimum 3/4" from board edges
  • End distance: Minimum 3" from ply ends

Joint Placement:

  • Middle ply: Joints at 8', 16', 24' (every 8 feet)
  • Outer plies: Stagger so joints fall at 4', 12', 20' and 12', 20', 28' respectively
  • This creates a broken joint pattern - no more than 2 plies joined at any point

Assembly Steps:

  1. Lay first ply (bottom) - joints at 8', 16', 24'
  2. Lay second ply - joints at 4', 12', 20', 28' (offset 4' from bottom)
  3. Lay third ply (top) - joints at 12', 20', 28' (offset 4' from middle)
  4. Nail each interface with 3 rows of 16d nails at 12" o.c.

Code Reference: IRC R502.3.1 requires floor beams to be constructed to resist uplift and lateral forces. The staggered joint pattern prevents weak planes.

Posts: Space posts at maximum 8' o.c. for 2x12 girders (IRC R502.3.2).

Safety: Wear eye protection when nailing - 16d nails require significant force. Consider using a pneumatic nailer for consistent penetration.

512 tokens · 9.7s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Nailing Pattern (IRC 2021 Table R602.3(1) / NDS):

  • Fastener: 16d common nails (0.162" × 3½").
  • Pattern: Two rows, staggered, at 16" o.c. along the length.
  • End distance: Minimum 3" from board ends.
  • Edge distance: Minimum ¾" from edges (center nails in the 11¼" width).
  • Total: ~48 nails per 16-ft layer (24 per row × 2 rows).

Joint Placement (Critical):

  • Only over posts (supports). Never in mid-span.
  • Stagger joints between plies: No two adjacent plies break at the same post.
  • 32-ft span / 16-ft stock = 2 joints per ply.
  • Example layout (Posts at 0', 16', 32'):
  • Ply 1 (Bottom): 16' board (0–16) + 16' board (16–32). Joint at 16' (mid-post).
  • Ply 2 (Middle): 16' board (0–16) + 16' board (16–32). Joint at 16' (mid-post) — WRONG if aligned with Ply 1.
  • Correct Stagger: Use 8' + 8' + 16'? No, stock is 16'. You cannot stagger 16' stock on 16' post spacing without butting two joints at the same post.
  • Solution: Order 12' and 20' stock (or 10'/22') to stagger joints at quarter-points (8', 24') over posts, or add a mid-span post at 16' to create 16' bays. With only end posts (0', 32'), 16' stock forces all joints at mid-span — unacceptable for a girder.

If you must use 16' stock on 32' span:

  1. Add a post at 16' (creating two 16' spans). Joints land at 16' post. Stagger plies: Ply 1 breaks at 16'; Ply 2 runs full 32' (impossible with 16' stock) — still fails.
  2. Only compliant option: Use longer stock (20'+) or add posts to create ≤12' bays allowing stagger.

Bottom line: 16' stock + 32' span + two end posts = code violation (IRC R502.6). Change stock lengths or add posts.

741 tokens · 25.1s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.