BlueCollarBench

Trades/Automotive & Diesel

Automotive & DieselTask AU-006journeymanKnowledgeUS

Got a Honda with a steady misfire on #3, coils and plugs swapped, injector swapped, still on #3.

Prompt as given to every model

Got a Honda with a steady misfire on #3, coils and plugs swapped, injector swapped, still on #3. When do I go to a compression test versus a leak-down, and what results tell me it's mechanical?

Model answers

Pick up to two to compare side by side. Score chips fill in as the judge grades.

Laguna S 2.1Score —

Compression Test First — it's quick and tells you a lot.

When to do it: Anytime a cylinder acts up after ruling out ignition and fuel. Since you've swapped coils, plugs, and injectors with no change, mechanical is next.

Compression Test Procedure:

  • Warm engine, all plugs out, throttle wide open
  • Crank 4-5 compression strokes per cylinder
  • Compare readings

What's "mechanical":

  • Low compression on #3 only = mechanical problem in that cylinder
  • Normal: 140-180 psi, within 10% of other cylinders
  • If #3 reads significantly lower (say, 90 psi while others are 160+), you've got a mechanical issue

Then go to Leak-Down:

  • Only after compression test confirms low pressure
  • Requires compressed air (90-100 psi)
  • Listen for where air escapes:
  • Hissing from intake = intake valve
  • Hissing from exhaust = exhaust valve
  • Bubbles in radiator = head gasket or cracked head
  • Hissing from oil cap/PCV = rings/piston

Red flags requiring a pro:

  • Any coolant loss or overheating history
  • Bubbles in cooling system during leak-down
  • Head gasket failure on aluminum Honda blocks often needs machining

Bottom line: Compression test first. If #3 is low, leak-down to pinpoint. If it's valves or gasket, you may need a shop unless you're experienced with head work.

440 tokens · 7.4s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.

Nemotron 3 Ultra 550BScore —

Do a compression test first. It’s faster, requires only a gauge, and tells you if the cylinder can build pressure. If compression is within 10–15% of the other cylinders (typically >150 psi on a healthy Honda), the rings, valves, and head gasket are likely sealing well enough to run. Move to ignition/sensor diagnostics (CKP/CMP correlation, wiring, ECU driver).

Go straight to leak-down if:

  1. Compression is low on #3.
  2. Compression is "good" but the misfire is load-dependent (suggests a sealing issue only under dynamic conditions).
  3. You suspect a burnt valve, bent valve, or head gasket breach between cylinders.

*Leak-down tells you where the air goes:*

  • Intake manifold (throttle body): Intake valve sealing failure (burnt/bent/carbon).
  • Exhaust pipe/tailpipe: Exhaust valve sealing failure.
  • Radiator/coolant overflow (bubbles): Head gasket breach or cracked head/block.
  • Dipstick tube/PCV/oil cap: Ring/cylinder wall wear or piston damage.
  • Adjacent spark plug hole (pull #2 & #4 plugs): Head gasket breach between cylinders.

Mechanical "Smoking Gun" Thresholds (Honda typical):

  • Compression: < 100 psi = major mechanical fault. > 20% variance from highest cylinder = mechanical fault.
  • Leak-down: > 20% total leakage = engine needs work. > 10% difference between cylinders = fault in the high-leak cylinder. Listen at the ports to pinpoint the component.

Pro Tip: On Hondas, verify valve adjustment before leak-down. A tight (zero lash) valve holds the valve open, mimicking a burnt valve on leak-down and killing compression. Check lash cold per FSM specs.

533 tokens · 14.4s

Judge rubric · pending

Not graded yet. Grading starts when the exam run completes.